Look at the biggest cinema releases today and a familiar pattern emerges: sequels, reboots, live-action adaptations and remakes. Instead of introducing new characters, studios increasingly return to stories audiences already know. There is a commercial reason for this, but it raises a more important question: are studios relying on familiar names so heavily that the quality of the films themselves is becoming secondary?
The box office explains why this strategy continues. In 2024, the ten highest-grossing films worldwide were all connected to existing franchises or established intellectual properties (IP), including Inside Out 2, Deadpool & Wolverine, Moana 2 and Dune: Part Two. These films attracted enormous audiences, with Inside Out 2 alone earning approximately US$1.7 billion worldwide. For studios, the message is difficult to ignore familiar stories already have an audience, making them easier to market than completely unfamiliar ideas.
But attracting an audience and satisfying one are two different things.
A recognisable character, a popular actor and an impressive trailer can generate excitement long before audiences know whether the script is any good. Fans may buy tickets out of loyalty, while others watch simply because the film is dominating social media discussions. By the time viewers discover that the story feels repetitive or the performances fail to convince, the ticket has already been purchased. Regret and sequel fatigue start sinking in.
This does not mean audiences are foolish for watching these films. Studios understand how nostalgia, fan loyalty and online attention influence purchasing decisions. The problem arises when these factors become more important than what the film delivers.
The performance of Joker: Folie à Deux illustrates the limits of relying on an established property. The 2019 Joker earned approximately US$1.08 billion worldwide. Its 2024 sequel, starring Joaquin Phoenix and Lady Gaga, earned around US$207.5 million against a reported US$190 million production budget. It also received a CinemaScore grade of D from opening-night audiences, reflecting a sharply divided reception. Although box-office revenue alone cannot determine a film’s quality or profitability, the sequel demonstrates that a successful character and a recognisable title cannot guarantee another commercial hit.
The consequences go beyond individual disappointing releases. When studios repeatedly invest in properties with existing fan bases, original films must compete for attention, funding and marketing resources against projects that already have a commercial advantage. New stories may therefore struggle to receive the same opportunities, even when they have strong creative potential.
The answer is not necessarily to stop making movie remakes, sequels or adaptations. Some of the best films come from existing stories. What matters is whether filmmakers bring something meaningful to them. A remake should offer a fresh perspective, a sequel should develop its characters, and an adaptation should have a strong reason to exist beyond its familiar title to avoid fatigue.
Studios need to invest in better scripts, thoughtful casting and creative direction instead of assuming that nostalgia will do the selling. Audiences can also look beyond familiar characters, check reviews and give original films a chance.
A familiar name may sell the ticket, but it should never be mistaken for a guarantee of a good film.



